UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: ELIZABETH AND JOHN CALVERT

When a wealthy Lowcountry power-couple confronts their financial manager over missing funds, they immediately vanish from their Hilton Head Island retreat. Unanswered questions haunt a tale of deadly greed in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Elizabeth and John Calvert (Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office)

Police: Man in Missing Couple Case Kills Self (NBC News)

Police Search Home of Missing Hilton Head Couple’s Business Associate (The Island Packet)

Calverts, Missing 9 Months, Dead and Long-Time Suspect Likely Killed Them, Sheriff Says (The Island Packet)

10 Years Later, SC Couples’ Disappearance Remains a Mystery (The State)

Evidence: S.C. Couple Murdered in March (Savannah Now)

The Impact of Obesity on Skeletal Muscle Strength and Structure Through Adolescence to Old Age (DJ Tomlinson et al / Biogerontology via the National Library of Medicine)

Timeline: Hilton Head Couple’s Disappearance and the Death of The Man Detectives Say Killed Them (Graham Cawthon / WJCL News)

Court Offers Details on How Harbour Town Couple Died (The Associated Press / GoUpstate)

What Happened to John and Liz Calvert? After 17 Years, Search Continues for Hilton Head Couple (Brooke Butler / WJCL News)

If you know anything about the disappearances of Elizabeth and John Calvert, please call the Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office at 843-524-2777, or—if you prefer to remain anonymous—the South Carolina Crime Stoppers at 1-888-274-6372.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: JACLYN DOWALIBY

When a seven year-old girl is abducted from her suburban Chicago home and murdered, investigators initially suspect those closest to her. A tumultuous search for her killer takes a series of shocking turns in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

People vs. Dowaliby (leagle.com)

Who Killed Jaclyn Dowaliby? The Case Remains Open and Chilling (Investigation Discovery)

Prosecutors Reveal Dowaliby Evidence (Chicago Tribune)

National Registry of Exonerations: David Dowaliby

Violent Crimes Against Children (FBI.gov)

Girl Missing and Clues Scarce (Chicago Tribune via newspapers.com)

Chicago Tribune Sunday, March 12, 1989 ed. (Chicago Tribune via newspapers.com)

Hernandez, Perry (Illinois State Police Sex Offender Registry)

Lawyers Cite Incident Similar to Case of Dowalibys’ Daughter (Matt O’Connor / Chicago Tribune via newspapers.com)

Chicago Tribune, Tue, Apr 10, 1990 ed. (Chicago Tribune via newspapers.com)

‘A Parents’ Nightmare’ Sentenced (Chicago Tribune via newspapers.com)

If you know anything about the death of Jaclyn Dowaliby, please call Cook County Crime Stoppers at 1-800-535-7867.

 

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: CYNTHIA ANDERSON

When a young legal secretary disappears after being haunted by recurring dreams of abduction and murder, her unsolved case becomes—and still is—one of the most mysterious in the state of Ohio. An array of compelling possibilities are explored in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Woman’s Disappearance a Mystery After 30 Years (Toledo Blade)

Dad Clings to Hope for Daughter Who Disappeared in ’81 (Toledo Blade)

Cynthia Anderson (Unsolved Mysteries)

Stalking (Bureau of Justice Statistics)

Supreme Court Disbars Toledo and Fostoria Attorneys, Suspends Two (Supreme Court of Ohio)

Judge Allows Release of Man Who Confessed to 3 Killings (AP News)

Crime in Ohio 1980 (Ohio Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation)

Anthony and Nathaniel Cook (Murderpedia)

Toledo’s Most Prolific Serial Killer Faces Parole: Families of Victims, Prosecutor Speak Out (Brian Dugger / WTOL11 News)

Killer Goes Free: Nathaniel Cook Released from Prison (Jennifer Feehan / Toledo Blade)

United States v. Rodriguez, 50 F. Supp. 2d 717 (N.D. Ohio 1999)

Lawyer Suspect in Killing (The News-Messenger via newspapers.com)

TOLEDO BAR ASSOCIATION v. NELLER (2003) (Ohio Supreme Court via FindLaw.com)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Cynthia Anderson, please contact the Toledo Crime Stoppers at (419) 255-1111. 

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: SHELLEY SIKES

When a young Texan woman fails to return home after a late night of waiting tables, her car is found—abandoned and blood-stained—in the heart of the notorious Texas Killing Fields. An unexpected lead results in the untangling of a twisted story in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Missing Pieces: A Killer’s Secret (KHOU11)

Shelley Kathleen Sikes (findagrave.com)

Index Crime Analysis 3: Murder (Texas DPS)

Zwarst v. State: Court of Appeals of Texas, Houston, Fourteenth District Nov 30, 1989 (via casetext.com)

Man Convicted in One of ‘I-45 Killings’ Cases Dies in Prison (Dallas Police News)

Sikes Case Reward Offered (The Galveston Daily News via newspapers.com)

Shelley Sikes’ Family Still Hopeful (The Galveston Daily News via newspapers.com)

Officers Search for Woman (The Galveston Daily News via newspapers.com)

Bloody Car of Missing Teen Found (The Monitor via newspapers.com)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Shelley Sikes, please call the Galveston County Sheriff’s Office at 409-766-2300.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: RASHAWN BRAZELL

When a Brooklyn teen disappears without a trace, a nightmarish discovery in a subway tunnel turns a missing person report into a homicide investigation. Investigators discover and accuse an alleged serial killer in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

New York State Unified Court System (Database)

Suspect in 2005 Cold-Case Killing of Dismembered Brooklyn Teen Linked to 2nd Teen Slaying (PIX11)

Rashawn Brazell’s Accused Killer Claims Alibi (Gay City News)

Snakes, a Life of Crime and Eventually Two Murder Charges (New York Times)

A Mother’s Fight for Finding Her Son’s Killers (Brooklyn Ink)

Cold Cases with Dismemberment Re-Examined for Possible Link to Suspected NYC Killer (abc7NY)

Cold Case Closed: Justice for Rashawn Brazell | Going in with Brian Vines (video)

Man Arrested in 2005 Brooklyn Subway Body Parts Case (Kwegyirba Croffie / CNN)

Murder Case Involving Dismembered Teen Dismissed in Brooklyn Court: DA (Mary Murphy / PIX11 News)

N.Y.C. Man Suspected of 2005 Beheading May Be a Serial Killer: Police (Chris Harris / people.com)

Defense Questions Key Evidence in Rashawn Brazell Murder (Duncan Osborne / Gay City News)

 People v. Govan (Kings County Supreme Court via casetext.com)

Man Convicted in 2004 Brooklyn Cold Case Murder Gets 25 Years to Life in Prison (ABC7 News)

Cold Cases with Dismemberment Re-Examined for Possible Link to Suspected NYC Killer (Darla Miles / ABC7 News)

If you have any information on the death of Rashawn Brazell, please call the NYPD Crime Stoppers’ tipline at 1-800-577-TIPS OR submit an anonymous tip online here.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: BEN MCDANIEL

When a scuba enthusiast embarks on a perilous cave dive alone and fails to return, it’s initially assumed that “the vortex” has claimed another victim. However, lack of a body and suspicious circumstances force authorities to consider other possibilities, including foul play, in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Missing Diver Loved Adventure (Cindy Wolff / The Commercial Appeal via Newspapers.com)

Parents of Lost Diver Pin Hopes for Closure on Team of Dogs (Tampa Bay Times / Ben Montgomery)

Expert: Family Searching for Body That Doesn’t Exist (Jackson County Floridian)

 He’s Not in There (The Commercial Appeal via PressReader)

Man Who Drowned Was an Expert Cave Diver (Tampa Bay Times)

Local Dive Expert to be Featured on TV Show ‘Disappeared’ (Deborah Buckhalter / The Commercial Appeal via newspapers.com)

Beyond the Last Restriction (Ben Montgomery / Tampa Bay Times)

Editorial: Turning Sunshine Into Shadow (Rachel Kaylor / Florida Society of News Editors)

Questions Remain About Lowell Kelly’s Death (Tom McLaughlin / Northwest Florida Daily News)

Theories About Collierville Diver’s Disappearance Swirl in Vortex of Unanswered Questions (Cindy Wolff / The Commercial Appeal)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Ben McDaniel, please call the Holmes County Sheriff’s Office at 850-547-3681.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: JENNIFER HARRIS

When a Texas woman returns to her small hometown to start over, she vanishes and is found dead in the Red River. Evidence suggests she died at the hands of someone she knew well, but her case remains unsolved in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

“Unsolved Murder Case is the Talk of Small Texas Town 17 Years Later” (CBS News)

“Father of Murder Victim Jennifer Harris Holds New Conference” (The Fannin County Leader)

“48 Hours to Feature Jennifer Harris Case” (Herald Democrat)

“Homicide Trends in the United States, 1980-2008” (Bureau of Justice Statistics)

Homicide Leading Cause of Death for Pregnant Women in The US (Harvard School of Public Health)

Texas Rangers Cold Case Investigation Details: Jennifer Harris (Texas Department of Public Safety)

Dad Who Spent 22 Years Trying to Find Daughter’s Killer Dies by Suicide in Front of Sheriff’s Office (Amelia Neath / The Independent)

Father of Cold Case Murder Victim Commits Suicide in Front of Fannin County Sheriff’s Office (Erin Pellet / KXII News)

New People Sworn In to Serve Fannin County (Talaiya Munson / KXII News)

Also noteworthy:

Check out Red Rabbit Justice, an effort by Jennifer’s brother-in-law (who happens to be a filmmaker) and others to produce a documentary film about her case. They are offering a $50,000 reward in relation to Jennifer’s case.

If you know anything about the death of Jennifer Harris, please contact Texas Crime Stoppers at  1-800-252-TIPS. You can remain anonymous.

UNSOLVED MOTHER-DAUGHTER HOMICIDE / DISAPPEARANCE: NIKKI & ARIANNA FITTS

When a young California girl goes missing and her mom is found murdered, one family seems to be at the center of it all. From a self-declared street preacher to a babysitter with a murderous past, a host of suspicious individuals haunt the story of a missing child who investigators believe is still alive in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Where is Arianna Fitts? (Nuala Sawyer Bihari / SanFrancisco Weekly)

SanFrancisco Police Release New Info in Search for Missing Girl, Mother’s Homicide (Bay City News)

Car Seized in Connection with Missing San Francisco Toddler, Dead Mother (Cheryl Hurd / NBC Bay Area)

A Mom was Found Buried in an SF Park. Her Daughter May Still Be Alive. (Katie Dowd / SF Gate)

I-Team: Search for Missing Girl Leads to Las Vegas; Aunt Clings to Hope for Niece (Vanessa Murphy / 8 News Now)

FBI Releases New Image of a 2 1/2 Year Old Girl Who Went Missing More Than 8 Years Ago (Amber Lee / KTVU News)

FBI Releases Age-Progressed Photo for 2-Year-Old Girl Who Went Missing in 2016 (NBC Bay Area)

$250,000 Reward Offered in Search for Girl Whose Mother Was Killed in San Francisco in 2016 (Jermaine One / 10 News San Diego

Nicole Fitts Homicide, Arianna Fitts Missing (San Francisco Police Department)

Do you recognize the child pictured above?

Arianna Fitts was only 2.5 when she went missing in 2016. She may resemble the age-progressed picture included above. She may still be alive, possibly in California’s Bay Area or the Las Vegas, Nevada area.

Do you recognize the wooden board pictured above?

The board, which bears a spray-painted symbol, was used to cover Nikki Fitts’ body after it was dumped in a San Francisco park. If you know where the board may have come from, investigators want to know.

If you know anything about the disappearance of Arianna Fitts and / or the death of Nikki Fitts, please submit a secure, anonymous tip here or call the San Francisco FBI field office at (415) 553-7400, or the San Francisco Police Department at San Francisco Police Department at 415-575-4444.

If your tip leads to the identification, arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for Nikki’s murder and Arianna’s disappearance you may be eligible for a $250,000 reward offered by the San Francisco Police Department, plus a $10,000 reward offered by Best Buy.

UNSOLVED DISSAPEARANCE: ZEBB QUINN

When an 18-year-old disappears under suspicious circumstances in Asheville, North Carolina, investigators are left to navigate a minefield of unbelievable stories and even more unbelievable people. An unsolved disappearance tangles with a would-be love triangle and the murder of a celebrity chef in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

A Murder Runs Through It: Zebb Quinn (Leslie Stahlhut via medium.com)

SPIN Magazine, Feb. 2001 ed. – Vol. 17, No. 2, “The Vanishing” (SPIN Media LLC via Google Books)

Compassion, Empathy May Have Led to Murders of ‘Food Network Star’ Contestant and Husband, Say Friends (Jeff Truesdell / People Magazine)

Warrant Details Zebb Quinn-Related Search at Leicester Property (Sabian Warren / Citizen Times)

In Teen Murder Plea Deal, Defense Claims Love Triangle Motive; Prosecutors Skeptical (Joel Burgess / Asheville Citizen Times)

Former Friend Shares About ‘Pathological Liar’ Owens Ahead of Plea Deal in Zebb Quinn Case (Kimberly King / ABC15 News)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Zebb Quinn, please call the Buncombe County Sheriff’s Office at (828) 250-4503.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: SUZANNE JOVIN

When one of the brightest students at a prestigious Ivy League university is fatally stabbed in plain sight, police scramble to determine who’s responsible. In a campus full of brilliant minds, one outsmarts all the rest, literally getting away with murder on this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Murder Most Yale (Suzanna Andrews / Vanity Fair)

Jovin Murder Mystery Continues 20 Years Later (Randall Beach / New Haven Register)

Ivy League Cold Case: A New Look at the 1998 Killing of Yale Student Suzanne Jovin (Sarah Cody / WTNH News)

With Yale Student’s Slaying Still Unsolved, Cold Case Investigators Reach Out to Public (Randall Beach / New Haven Register)

Tips in 1998 Slaying of Yale Student Suzanne Jovin Focus on Disturbed Grad Student (Randall Beach / New Haven Register)

Investigators Ask for Public’s Help in Solving 25-Year-Old Homicide Cold Case in New Haven (WTNH News)

SUBSTANTIAL REWARD AVAILABLE

Yale University is still offering a $100,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of Jovin’s killer, while the state is offering a $50,000 reward. 

If you have any information about the murder of Suzanne Jovin, please call the investigative tipline at: 1-866-623-8058. Or, e-mail investigators at: jovin.case@ct.gov.