When two teens are found fatally shot inside a sandwich shop just months after surviving the Columbine High School Massacre, the Valentine’s Day double-homicide shocks their community. Investigators offer a major reward for information in hopes of solving a cold case in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Nicholas Kunselman and Stephanie Hart-Grizzell were students at Columbine High School, and survivors of the Columbine High School Massacre. 10 months after the massacre, they were both gunned down in an unrelated shooting. Image source: family photo.These suspect sketches depict a man who a witness saw running away from the double-homicide scene. Image source: police image.Approximately one year after Nicholas and Stephanie’s double-homicide, another teenager was fatally shot while at work in a Colorado Springs Subway. Three suspects were identified and charged. This image shows all three suspects, plus the victim, Blaine Steele. Image source: the Pueblo Chieftain.Nicholas Kunselman was 15-years-old when he was fatally shot while working at a Subway restaurant in Littleton, Colorado on February 14th, 2000. His girlfriend, Stephanie, was killed alongside him. Their double-homicide remains unsolved. Image source: family photo.Stephanie Hart-Grizzell was 16-years-old when she was fatally shot at a Subway restaurant in Littleton, Colorado on the February 14th, 2000. She had gone to the restaurant to pick up her boyfriend, Nicholas, who worked there. He was killed alongside her, and their double-homicide remains unsolved. Image source: family photo.Investigators are appealing to the public for help in solving Stephanie and Nick’s case. Anyone with information may remain anonymous, and may be anonymous for a substantial reward. This flyer distributed by the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office is dated; the reward currently stands at $100,000. Image source: Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office.
Whether you call in your tip or submit it online, you may remain anonymous if you wish. If your tip leads to resolution in this case, you may be eligible for a $100,000 reward.
When a western New York woman vanishes during a night of dancing at a popular nightclub, the focus of the investigation quickly turns to the last person seen with her: a local state trooper. Investigators seek the public’s help in solving a case they refuse to give up on in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Leichia Reilly was 21-years-old when she went missing from West Seneca, New York on January 30th, 1985. Investigators believe her disappearance was a result of foul play, and that she is deceased. Image source: family photo.Pictured: a poster distributed by the West Seneca Police Department after Leichia’s disappearance. It shows Leichia, along with the person she was last seen with: Daniel D. Rose. Image source: West Seneca Police Department.A 1984 article from The Times Union details the outcome of an assault then New York State Trooper Daniel D. Rose committed against a teenager. Daniel D. Rose of western New York is the last person ever seen with Leichia, who is believed to be deceased. Image source: The Times Union.A 2020 article by Dan Herbeck for the Buffalo News revisits Leichia’s Case. Leichia left a nightclub with then New York State Trooper Daniel D. Rose, and has not been seen since. The Buffalo News has been reporting on her case from 1985 through present day. Image source: Mark Melville / Buffalo News
When a Florida woman disappears from her home without warning in 2023, she leaves all of her belongings behind—even her shoes. Investigators uncover other shocking crimes while attempting to solve a presumed no-body homicide in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
The Mt Dora Police shared this bulletin with the public after Nicole Baldwin was reported missing by her daughter. Nicole was last seen wearing a nightgown similar to the one pictured. Image source: Mt Dora Police Department.Nicole lived in and went missing from Lake County, Florida. Lake County is home to more than 1,000 lakes, and is adjacent to multiple nature preserves. Investigators have searched numerous bodies of water in an effort to find Nicole, who they believe is a victim of homicide. Image source: Google Maps.Nicole Baldwin was last seen alive in her Mt Dora, Florida home on November 2nd, 2023. she was 41-years-old, and a mother of three. Investigators believe she was murdered. Image source: family photo.Nicole required medication to treat a chronic health condition. She went missing without her medication, or any other belongings, and is presumed deceased. Investigators are treating her case as a homicide. Image source: family photo.Here, Nicole is pictured with her husband, Brett Baldwin. After Nicole vanished, investigators searched Brett’s phone and found evidence of other crimes unrelated to Nicole’s disappearance. Brett was prosecuted and sentenced to 15 years in federal prison. Image source: family photo.
United States of America v. Brett Baldwin (United States Districted Court for the Middle District of Florida)
If you know anything about the disappearance of Nicole Baldwin, please call the Mount Dora police at 352-735-7130, or call Crimeline at 1-800-423-8477. By calling the crimeline, you may remain anonymous if you wish. If your tip leads to resolution in Nicole’s case, you may be eligible for a $10,000 reward.
When firefighters respond to a blaze at a suburban Atlanta apartment complex in September of 2025, they find the remains of an accomplished playwright, along with clear signs of foul play. Investigators seek the public’s help in identifying a neighborhood prowler believed to have been targeting women—like the victim—who lived alone in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Olivia Matthews was 32-years-old when she was murdered in her own home on the night of September 2nd, 2025. Her case is unsolved, and a substantial reward is offered for information leading to the identification and conviction of her killer. Image source: portrait by photographer Lola Scott.Olivia was killed inside of her apartment at the Bella 10 Apartments on Windy Hill Rd SE in Smyrna, Georgia. Part of the complex is pictured here. Olivia lived in a ground-floor unit. Image source: Google Maps.Olivia was an award-winning playwright known not only for the quality of her work, but the quality of her character. Those who knew her say that she was inclusive, kind, and accepting of others for who they were. Image source: portrait by Lola Scott.Do you recognize this person? Investigators are trying to ID him, and they need the public’s help. He is considered a potential person of interest in relation to Olivia’s case. He has not been named a suspect. Please contact Atlanta Crime Stoppers or the Smyrna Police Department if you know who he is. You may remain anonymous if you wish via Atlanta Crime Stoppers. Image source: residential security camera footage distributed to the public by the Smyrna Police Department.
If you know anything about the death of Olivia Matthews, please call the Atlanta Crime Stoppers at 404-577-8477, or submit at tip via the Greater Atlanta Crime Stoppers’ Website. You may remain anonymous if you wish, and if your tip leads to resolution in Olivia’s case, you may be eligible for up to $20,000 in rewards.
When a foreign exchange student from Japan enrolls at a small private college in Texas, all goes well until she hosts a modest end-of-semester party in her apartment. Investigators retrieve her remains from a deliberately-set fire and discover the scorched evidence of a brutal crime in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Mikiko excelled academically, earning excellent grades at Texas Lutheran University. She is missed by her loved ones in Japan, including her parents and younger sister. Image source: family photo.Mikiko was murdered inside of her apartment at Sunset Terrace Apartments in Seguin, Texas. The building (pictured) is still there today. Investigators want to hear from anyone who may have been living or staying at the apartments at the time of her murder, and may remember anything from that night / morning. Image source: Google Maps.Jose Baldomero Flores III is a convicted murderer who killed two women in the San Antonio metropolitan area, and attempted to destroy evidence of the crimes through arson. One of his victims was a friend of his who attended Texas Lutheran University at the same time as Mikiko. He has not been named a suspect in Mikko’s case. Image source: police photo.Mikiko Kasahara was 21-years-old when she was murdered inside of her off-campus apartment in Seguin, Texas in 2002. She was an exchange student studying at Texas Lutheran University, and originally from Japan. Her murder remains unsolved. Image source: family photo.
If you know anything about the death of Mikiko Kasahara, please call the Texas Crime Stoppers Hotline at 1-800-252-8477, or submit a tip via their website HERE. You may remain anonymous if you wish, and a $3,000 reward is currently being offered for information that leads to resolution in Mikiko’s case.
If you prefer, you may also contact the Texas Rangers or Seguin Police Department directly, although you won’t be eligible to receive the award unless you go through the Texas Crime Stoppers.
When skeletal remains are discovered in the attic of an abandoned Washington farmhouse, the years-old mystery of a missing woman’s whereabouts is finally solved. However, the mystery of how and why she died remains in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Donna lived alone in a small house near the intersection of Wilson Road and US 12 in Salkum, Washington. She vanished from her home and her remains were found years later in the attic of another (abandoned) building on her family’s 600+ acre farm property. Image source: Google Maps.This 1983 newspaper clipping shows Donna’s daughters standing in the kitchen of her home after her disappearance, speaking to media. We were unable to locate a photo of Donna herself. Image source: Associated Press.
When an adventurous Canadian woman visits New Hampshire’s White Mountains for a solo hiking retreat, she’s ambushed by a killer. Investigators seek the public’s help to solve an apparently random homicide in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Louise went missing while hiking a trail in the pictured area within New Hampshire’s White Mountains. Her vehicle was found parked in a lot at the trailhead, and her body was eventually found approx. 200 feet / 61 meters off of the Glen Boulder Trail. Image source: Google Maps.Louise Chaput was an adventurous, intelligent and independent woman who loved the outdoors. She worked as a professional psychologist, and was a mom of two. Her murder is unsolved. Image source: family photo.Louise’s car (pictured) was located in a parking lot at the Glen Ellis Falls Trailhead. Image source: police photo.Do you recognize this backpack? Louise was carrying one like it when she was attacked, and her killer took it with them. They may have used it afterward, and may even still have it. Louise had affixed a “Canada insignia” to her backpack. Image source: Lugger,Louise was a capable and experienced hiker. She was attacked and killed by an unidentified assailant while hiking a popular trail in New Hampshire’s White Mountains. Her murder remains unsolved. Image source: family photo.
If you know anything about the death of Louise Chaput, please contact the New Hampshire Department of Justice’s Cold Case Unit at 603-223-3856 or fill out their online tip form HERE.
When two remarkably similar Northern Virginia women are murdered just months apart in nearly identical crimes, their neighbors fear that a serial offender is at large. DNA evidence proves them right and investigators strive to identify a serial killer who preys on the elderly in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Marion Marshall was 72-years-old when she was murdered in her Springfield, Virginia home in August of 2006. Image source: Virginia DMV.Marion Newman was 74-years-old when she was murdered in her Springfield, Virginia home in November of 2006. Image source: Virginia DMV.Marion Marshall and Marion Newman lived in the Springfield, Virginia neighborhoods of Crestwood and Edsall Park. Their homes were approximately 2 miles (or approximately 3 kilometers) apart. Image source: Google Maps.Marion Marshall was a retired librarian who devoted her time and energy to volunteerism, particularly to teaching English as a second language. She was generous, and dedicated to improving the lives of others in her community. Image source: family photo.Marion Newman devoted her time and energy to volunteerism, particularly to working at local animal shelters. She was also extremely devoted to her 92-year-old mother, who she spent hours with every day. She was known as “Sweetie” to her family. Image source: family photo.This photo shows Marion Newman’s custom-made diamond ring, which she frequently wore. It has not been seen since her murder, and it’s believed that her killer may have taken it as a trophy. Image source: family photo.These composite images from Parabon NanoLabs depict what Marion Marshall and Marion Newman’s murderer may have looked like at ages 25, 40 and 55. DNA analysis revealed that their killer was a Hispanic male. His identity remains unknown. These images are predictive approximations, and may not match his exact appearance. Image source: Parabon NanoLabs.
When a 13-year-old girl runs away from a Baltimore area group home, she remains missing for months before her remains are found in a wooded area. Investigators strive to identify the predator who took a vulnerable child’s life in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Sarah Forrester was 13-years-old when she went missing from a children’s home in suburban Baltimore. A couple months later, her remains were found in a wooded area adjacent to an apartment complex. Her murder is unsolved. Image source: family photo.Sarah’s remains were found in a wooded area adjacent to a suburban Baltimore apartment complex. Whether or not her killer had any connection to the apartments is unknown. Image source: police photo.Sarah was missing for a couple of months before she was murdered. During that time, she stayed in a Baltimore suburb approximately 35 miles (or 56 kilometers) from the suburb from which she disappeared. Image source: Google Maps.Sarah’s remains were found in suburban Baltimore, a few miles north of the group home she’d disappeared from. Image source: Google Maps.Curtis McKissett was charged with 1st Degree Murder in relation to Sarah’s death less than a year after her murder. However, the charges were dismissed soon after. Image source: police photo.Darlene Giles was 31-years-old when she went missing from Baltimore County. She remained missing for 2.5 months before her remains were located in a wooded area. Like Sarah, she was a homicide victim, and had been fatally cut / stabbed. It’s unknown whether her case is related to Sarah’s in any way, but like Sarah’s, her case remains unsolved. Image source: family photo.
If you know anything about the death of Sarah Forrester—or the death of Darlene Giles—please call the Baltimore County Police Department at 410-887-3943. Or, text the Baltimore County Police Department’s Homicide and Missing Persons Unit at 443-862-9426, or email them homicide@baltimorecountymd.gov.
If you wish to remain anonymous, report your tip to Metro County Crime Stoppers. Check out their website—metrocrimestoppers.com—for information on how to submit a tip.
When a Colorado man brings his young daughter to work for a day, they both vanish under highly-suspicious circumstances, along with another employee. Investigators search for answers in a presumed case of triple-homicide in this episode of Last Seen Alive.
Pictured: Sarah Skiba with her dad, Paul Skiba. When one of Paul’s employee’s experienced a family emergency, Paul worked in their stead for a day, and brought his daughter along. They disappeared while on the job, along with another employee: Lorenzo Chivers. Image source: family photo.Sarah Skiba was just 9-year-old when she disappeared along with her dad, Paul, and his employee / co-worker Lorenzo. She was her mother’s only child. Her mother has never received answers regarding her disappearance. Image source: family photo.Lorenzo Chivers was a father of two, and is missed by his children and former wife. It’s believed that his boss, Paul, was the primary target of foul play, and that he was also harmed due to being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Image source: family photo.Pictured from left to right: 39-year-oldl Paul Skiba, 9-year-old Sarah Skiba and 36-year-old Lorenzo Chivers. All three disappeared together on February 7th, 1999, and are believed to be victims of foul play. Image source: family photos.Pictured: the moving truck that was found crookedly-parked in the company lot. It’s believed to be where at least two of the three victims were killed. Image source: police photo.
LAST SEEN ALIVE 