UNSOLVED CASES OF MISSING / MURDERED HIKERS

From sunrise hikes to foraging sessions, the unsolved cases included in this episode feature stories of victims who ventured into nature and never made it home. Each of these little-known cases are in critical need of tips from the public, so join us as we recount the final hikes of five separate victims in this special multi-case episode of Last Seen Alive.

Stories in this episode include:

  • The 1986 murder of Jane Pritchard, a botany student who was killed with a shotgun blast while studying botanical specimens in Delaware’s Blackbird State Forest.
  • The 2006 double-homicide of Mary and Susanna Stodden, a mother / daughter pair who were fatally shot while hiking together on Washington’s rugged Pinnacle Lake Trail.
  • The 2022 disappearance of Niqi Cavanaugh-De Calderon, a professional ballerina and avid forager who vanished during a walk in woods near Oregon’s Mt. Hood.
  • The 2023 murder of Dr Honoree Fleming, an accomplished academic who was fatally shot while hiking her favorite trail in Vermont’s picturesque lake region.

Unsolved Homicide: Jane Pritchard

Jane Pritchard was murdered in 1986 while conducting botanical research in Delaware’s Blackbird State Forest. Image source: family photo.

Sources used to research Jane Pritchard’s story:

Jane Pritchard (New Castle Police Department)

Cold Case Unit Tackles 1986 Killing of Student in Forest (Robin Brown / The News Journal)

Motive Remains Mystery in Slaying of Botanist (Tom Vesey / Washington Post)

What Distance Should Be Used to Pattern a Shotgun? (Phil Bourjaily / Field & Stream)

State v. Lloyd (Superior Court of Delaware via CaseText.com)

Meet the Men Who Are Solving Delaware’s Cold Murder Cases (Brandon Ambrosino / Delaware Today)

If you know anything about the death of Jane Pritchard, please contact the New Castle County Police’s Cold Case Homicide Squad at: 302-395-2781. Or, if you wish to remain anonymous, you can call Delaware Crime Stoppers at 800-847-3333, or submit a tip via their website: delaware.crimestoppersweb.com.

Unsolved Double-Homicide: Mary and Susanna Stodden

Susanna Stodden (left) a d her mother Mary Stodden (right) were murdered while hiking together at Pinnacle Lake in 2006. Image source: family photo.

Sources used to research Mary and Susanna Stodden’s story:

Cast Into the Path of a Killer (Tomas Alex Tizon)

Pinnacle Lake Murder Case is Cold, But Memory Still Burns (Eric Stevick / Everett Herald)

Man Still Searching for Who Killed His Wife, Daughter While They Hiked in Snohomish County 18 Years Ago (Erik Wilkinson / KING5 News)

Slain Hikers Were Avid About Outdoors (Scott Gutierrez and Jon Naito / Seattle Post-Intelligencer)

Pinnacle Lake (Washington Trails Association)

Stodden Cleared in Murder of Wife and Daughter More Than 12 Years Ago (Jennifer Sullivan /KOMO News)

If you know anything about the deaths of Mary and Susanna Stodden, please contact the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office at 425-388-3393.

Unsolved Disappearance: Niqola “Niqi” Cavanaugh-De Calderon

Sources used to research Niqola “Niqi” Cavanaugh-De Calderon’s story:

2022: Dance in the Rearview Mirror (Jamuna Chiarini / Oregon Artswatch)

Missing Person / NamUs #MP89950, Niqola A. Cavanaugh-De Calderon (NAMUS)

Agnieszka Laska Dancers (Oregon Cultural Trust)

Have you Seen Her? Missing Oregon Woman Last Seen Feb. 26th After Recent Medical Issue (KATU News)

Gender Identity Disparities in Criminal Victimization: National Crime Victimization Survey, 2017-2018 (Andrew R Flores et al. / American Journal of Public Health)

Unruptured Cerebral Aneurysms: Evaluation and Management (Norman Ajiboye et al. / Scientific World Journal)

If you know anything about the disappearance or whereabouts of Niqi Cavanaugh-De Calderon, please contact the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office at (503) 785-5000.

Unsolved Homicide: Dr Honoree Fleming

Sources used to research Dr Honoree Fleming’s story:

Who Killed Beloved College Dean Married to Pulitzer Prize Winner? Vermont Police Just Released a Sketch (Emily Palmer / people.com)

News In Brief: Former Middlebury professor Honoree Fleming killed in Castleton, Vt. (The Middlebury Campus / Catherine Goodrich and Susanna Schatz)

D&H Rail Trail (Vermont Department of Forests, Parks and Recreation)

‘Intelligence Coupled with Empathy’: Honoree Fleming Remembered as Dedicated Scientist, Caring Educator (Tiffany Tan / VT Digger)

If you have any information on the murder of Dr Honoree Fleming, please contact the Vermont State Police at 802-773-9101. Or, if you prefer to remain anonymous, use the Vermont State Police’s online tip form: vsp.vermont.gov/tipsubmit.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: ATTIIN SHAW

When a mom-of-four moves halfway around the world to a remote corner of northern Maine, she soon disappears from her new home. State investigators assume control of a case originally handled by a criminally corrupt small-town police department in this episode of Last Seen Alive

Sources used to research this episode:

Attiin Shaw Missing (WGAM News)

Maine State Police Conduct Search Related to Ongoing Search for Missing Woman (Marc Fortier / NECN)

Search for Missing Washburn Woman Last Seen in 2021 Continues (Brian Bouchard / WAGM News)

Authorities Search Washburn, Maine Residence in Connection to 2021 Disappearance of Attiin Shaw (Nicolás Viñuela / NBC News)

Could Attin Rachmawati Have Been Found After Disappearing 3 Years Ago? (Indonesian Lantern)

Mrs. Shaw’s Page (Attiin Shaw’s Personal Blog)

Immigrant South Asian Women at Greater Risk for Injury From Intimate Partner Violence (Anita Raj, PhD and Jay G. Silverman, PhD / American Journal of Public Health)

Battered Immigrants and US Citizen Spouses (Giselle Hass et al)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Attiin Shaw, please contact the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit at (207)532-5400.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: KELSEY EMILY COLLINS

When a teenage trafficking victim agrees to testify against her traffickers in criminal court, she goes missing before the case makes it to trial. The disappearance and probable murder of a vulnerable child shed light on the harsh realities of hidden in plain sight sex trafficking in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Sex Trafficking Victim Testifies, Then Vanishes (Patrick Oppmann / CNN)

Everett Mother Shares Tragic Loss to Fight Sex Trafficking (Eric Stevick / The Everett Herald)

Teen Missing After Testimony Against Pimp (Susan Kelleher / Seattle Times)

Hirschsprung’s Disease (Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia)

Emily’s Song: An Account of Emily’s Life and Disappearance, As Told by Her Mother (Sarah Collins)

Portland Man Sentenced to 188 Months in Prison for Sex Trafficking of a Minor (U.S. Attorney’s Office / FBI.gov)

Inmate Death at USP Coleman I (U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Prisons)

Child Sex Trafficking (National Center for Missing and Exploited Children)

Resources for Trafficking Victims / Families of Victims:

Team HOPE (An Initiative of the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children)

National (US) Human Trafficking Hotline: 1-888-373-7888

If you know anything about the disappearance of Kelsey Emily Collins, please contact the FBI’s Seattle Field Office at 206-622-0460.

CASE UPDATE #3: CHONG MOUA YANG’S KILLER CONVICTED

Beloved family man and avid hunter Chong Moua Yang was murdered on public land in Michigan on November 16th, 2018. On February 22nd, 2024, Thomas Olson (age 35, and also of Michigan) was convicted of his murder. Olson was one of two suspects originally charged with Chong’s murder. This case update episode covers Olson’s trial and sentencing.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: JULIE WEFLEN

When a hardworking Washington woman is abducted from a remote job site, a massive search is launched. Investigators explore the possibility that her case may be related to those of several other women who also vanished from the area and were never found in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Missing on the Job (Jody Lawrence-Turner / The Spokesman-Review)

Amateur Sleuth Says 25-Year-Old Case of Missing BPA Worker Julie Weflen ‘Can Be Solved’ (Richard Cockle / The Oregonian)

Unfound Podcast May 22, 2020 Episode: Julie Weflen (Ed Dentzel / Unfound Podcast)

Detectives Retrieve Belongings from Weflen’s Locker (Jody Lawrence-Turner / The Spokesman-Review)

Julie Ann Miner-Weflen (FindaGrave.com)

Man Quits Job to Hunt for Missing Wife (Daily Press, Friday December 25th 1987 Ed., Page 6, via newspapers.com)

Missing Woman’s Ex-Colleague Brings Attention to 1987 Case (Meghann M. Cuniff / The Spokesman-Review)

1981 Disappearance of 24-Year-Old Spokane Nurse Remains Unsolved, Family Pleading for Tips (Hayley Guenther / KHQ News)

Missing: Katherine Gregory (Leah Sottile / Inlander)

Cold Case Info Sought (CDA Press)

Case Not Closed (David Cole / CDA Press)

BPA Offering $25K Reward in Julie Weflen Case (Rob Kauder / KXLY News)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Julie Weflen, please contact the Spokane County Sheriff’s Office at 509-456-2233.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: COURTNEY HOLDEN

When a young Spokane, Washington woman goes missing, it’s not reported until more than a year later. Investigators unravel the story of a vanished woman whose adopted family called her their real-life “Cinderella” in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

“No One Was Speaking Up for Her, it Breaks My Heart:” Missing Spokane Mom Gone for Months Before Police Report Was Made (Hayley Guenther / KHQ News)

“I know Courtney was murdered”: Spokane Man Details Life in the Holden Home (KHQ News)

Investigation into Spokane Mother’s Disappearance Goes Cold, Court Case Against Adoptive Family Members Resolved (Hayley Guenther / KHQ News)

Missing Woman’s Family Arrested in Texas in Connection to Her Disappearance (Taylor Graham / KXLY News)

Lawyer: Relatives of Spokane Woman Feared Dead Want to Return Home After Texas Arrests, Clear Up ‘Sinister’ Accusations (Jared Brown / The Spokesman-Review)

‘I Could’ve Dug Deeper’: Friends Regret Not Reporting Missing Spokane Mom Sooner (Taylor Graham / KXLY News)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Courtney Holden, please call the Spokane Police Department’s tipline at: 509-242-8477.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: ANGELA FREEMAN

When a young Mississippi mom-to-be goes missing, evidence discovered by a remote, abandoned bridge suggests she was murdered. A killer remains at large—and potentially still within the community—in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Telling Lives Podcast (Elizabeth Christian)

The Hattiesburg American, Thursday, May 4th, 2000 Ed., Page 6 (The Hattiesburg American via newspapers.com)

Mother, Brother Looking for Answers 25 Years After Pregnant Mississippi Teen Disappears (Juliet Muir / NBC News)

29 Years Later, and the Angela Freeman Case Remains Open (Will Polston / WDAM News)

Missing: Angela Freeman Last Seen in Petal 28 Years Ago (WJTV News)

Petal Ranked “Safest City in Mississippi” (Eddie Robertson / WDAM News)

America Has the Highest Maternal Mortality Rate Among Developed Nations (Asima Ahmad / Fortune)

Homicide a Leading Cause of Death for US Pregnant Women (Rebecca B Lawn and Karestan C Koenan / BMJ, October 19th, 2022 ed.)

David Moody v. State of Mississippi (State of Mississippi via Justia.com)

25 Years of Waiting: ‘We Will Never Stop our Search for Angela’ (Lici Beveridge / Hattiesburg American)

If you have any information on the disappearance of Angela Freeman, please call the Petal Police Department at 601-544-5331, or the Perry County Sheriff’s Office at 601-964-8461.

BREAKING UPDATE: 3 MEN CHARGED WITH KELLE ANN WORKMAN’S MURDER

When a young Missouri woman was abducted from a cemetery and murdered, her violent death haunted her rural community for 35 years. Now, three men have finally been charged with her murder. The Ozark Mountains overshadow long-awaited investigative breakthroughs in this special breaking update episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Here’s How 2 Investigators Solved the 34-Year-Old Kelle Ann Workman Cold Case (Greta Cross and Marta Mieze / Springfield News Leader)

SW MO Investigators Helped Solving 35-Year-Old Cold Case (Fernanda Silva / KOAM News)

A Missouri Woman Was Killed in 1989. Three Men Are Now Charged in the Crime (AP News)

Brixey Resident is One of Three Men Arrested in 1989 Murder of Kelle Ann Workman (Ozark County Times)

Family Relieved After Three Charged with 25-Year-Old’s Murder in 1989 Cold Case (WSFA News)

Cold Case Arrests: 3 arrested in death of Douglas County woman in 1989 (KY3 News)

After 35 Years, 3 Men Charged in Relation to 1989 Ozarks Murder of Kelle Ann Workman (Greta Cross / Springfield News Leader)

Tip to Police Leads to Arrest of 3 Men in 1989 Rape and Murder in Missouri (Jesus Jimenez / New York Times)

Kelle Ann Workman (Find A Grave)

Report: Kelle’s Killer(s) Can Still Be Caught (Webster County Citizen / Fred Spriggs)

Untitled July 6, 1989 Article (Douglass County Herald)

Unsolved Slaying Haunts Family (Springfield News Leader, 1990, via Newspapers.com)

24 Year Old Woman Missing Since Friday (Douglas County Herald, 1989, via Newspapers.com)

Body of Missing Woman Found in Christian County (Douglas County Herald, 1989, via Newspapers.com)

Slaying Suspect Sticks by Alibi in Workman Case (Springfield News Leader, 1995, via Newspapers.com)

July 1996 Article (Springfield News Leader, 1996, via Newspapers.com)

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: DIANA VICARI

When a young Tucson, Arizona woman goes missing, her partial remains are discovered in a dumpster just days later. Potential suspects and unanswered questions haunt a case gone cold in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Mystery Shrouds 1992 Murder (Gabrielle Fimbres / The Tucson Citizen)

Diana Dawn Vicari (The Arizona Daily Star)

State v. Prion (2002) Supreme Court of Arizona (Supreme Court of Arizona via FindLaw.com)

State v. Lemuel Prion CR-99-0378-AP, Oral Argument Case Summary (Arizona Supreme Court)

Arizona Daily Star, Tuesday, October 27th, 1992 Ed., Page 2 (Arizona Daily Star via Newspapers.com)

Utah Inmate Indicted in 1992 Slaying (Deseret News)

The National Registry of Exonerations: Lemuel Prion (Alexandra Gross / University of Michigan Law School)

Woman Involved In ‘Brutalized’ Abuse Of Her Baby As a Teen Granted New Look At 1993 Case (Terri Jo Neff / Arizona Daily Independent)

ANGELA RENE LEEMAN v. STATE OF ARIZONA (Supreme Court of the United States)

ANGELA RENE LEEMAN, PETITIONER V. STATE OF ARIZONA, RESPONDENT (Supreme Court of the United States)

Mother, Boyfriend Sentenced to Life for ‘Atrocities’ Inflicted on 8-Month-Old (Joe Salkowski / Arizona Daily Star)

Tucson’s Top Unsolved Crimes (David Teibal / The Tucson Citizen)

If you know anything about the death of Diana Vicari, please call the Tucson Police Department directly at 520-791-4444 OR if you’d prefer to submit a tip anonymously, call 520-882-7463, or go to 88crime.org.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: BIANCA PIPER

When a girl goes missing from rural Missouri, hopes that she simply became lost during a walk are quickly extinguished. Investigators pursue answers in the potential abduction of a vulnerable child in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Sheriff to Implement a Cold Case Unit; Piper Disappearance Tops on The List (Shawn Singleton / Lincoln News Now)

Family Marking 10th Anniversary of Missing Foley Girl with Fading Hope (Susan Weich / St. Louis Post Dispatch)

Lincoln County Cold Case Gets Renewed Hope (First Alert 4 News)

‘You think about it every day’ | 13 years since Bianca Piper disappeared (Rachel Menitoff / KSDK News)

Historical Temperature Record: Foley, MO, March 10th, 2005 (wunderground.com)

Michael Devlin: Suspect is Called ‘Kind of a Plain Guy’ (Jeremy Kohler / St. Louis Post Dispatch)

What Happened to Convicted Kidnapper Michael J. Devlin? (William Kennedy / Grunge)

One Search, Two Boys Found: A Look Back at the Missouri Miracle (Tim O’Neil / The Southern Illinoisan)

The Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Efforts to Combat Crimes Against Children (FBI / US DOJ)

Pizza Manager’s Links to 1991 Abduction Investigated (KLTV News)

22 Years After Attempted Abduction, Victim Says He Learned it Was Michael Devlin (KMOV News)

The Relationship Between Victim Age and Gender Crossover Among Sex Offenders (Jill S. Levenson et al. / Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment, March 2008 Edition)

Suicide and Suicide Risk in Adolescents (Liwei L. Hua, MD, PhD et al. / American Academy of Pediatrics)

Mother of Missing Girl is Charged with Assault (Susan Weich / St. Louis Post-Dispatch)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Bianca Piper, please contact the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office at 636-528-8546.