UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: ANGELA FREEMAN

When a young Mississippi mom-to-be goes missing, evidence discovered by a remote, abandoned bridge suggests she was murdered. A killer remains at large—and potentially still within the community—in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Telling Lives Podcast (Elizabeth Christian)

The Hattiesburg American, Thursday, May 4th, 2000 Ed., Page 6 (The Hattiesburg American via newspapers.com)

Mother, Brother Looking for Answers 25 Years After Pregnant Mississippi Teen Disappears (Juliet Muir / NBC News)

29 Years Later, and the Angela Freeman Case Remains Open (Will Polston / WDAM News)

Missing: Angela Freeman Last Seen in Petal 28 Years Ago (WJTV News)

Petal Ranked “Safest City in Mississippi” (Eddie Robertson / WDAM News)

America Has the Highest Maternal Mortality Rate Among Developed Nations (Asima Ahmad / Fortune)

Homicide a Leading Cause of Death for US Pregnant Women (Rebecca B Lawn and Karestan C Koenan / BMJ, October 19th, 2022 ed.)

David Moody v. State of Mississippi (State of Mississippi via Justia.com)

25 Years of Waiting: ‘We Will Never Stop our Search for Angela’ (Lici Beveridge / Hattiesburg American)

If you have any information on the disappearance of Angela Freeman, please call the Petal Police Department at 601-544-5331, or the Perry County Sheriff’s Office at 601-964-8461.

BREAKING UPDATE: 3 MEN CHARGED WITH KELLE ANN WORKMAN’S MURDER

When a young Missouri woman was abducted from a cemetery and murdered, her violent death haunted her rural community for 35 years. Now, three men have finally been charged with her murder. The Ozark Mountains overshadow long-awaited investigative breakthroughs in this special breaking update episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Here’s How 2 Investigators Solved the 34-Year-Old Kelle Ann Workman Cold Case (Greta Cross and Marta Mieze / Springfield News Leader)

SW MO Investigators Helped Solving 35-Year-Old Cold Case (Fernanda Silva / KOAM News)

A Missouri Woman Was Killed in 1989. Three Men Are Now Charged in the Crime (AP News)

Brixey Resident is One of Three Men Arrested in 1989 Murder of Kelle Ann Workman (Ozark County Times)

Family Relieved After Three Charged with 25-Year-Old’s Murder in 1989 Cold Case (WSFA News)

Cold Case Arrests: 3 arrested in death of Douglas County woman in 1989 (KY3 News)

After 35 Years, 3 Men Charged in Relation to 1989 Ozarks Murder of Kelle Ann Workman (Greta Cross / Springfield News Leader)

Tip to Police Leads to Arrest of 3 Men in 1989 Rape and Murder in Missouri (Jesus Jimenez / New York Times)

Kelle Ann Workman (Find A Grave)

Report: Kelle’s Killer(s) Can Still Be Caught (Webster County Citizen / Fred Spriggs)

Untitled July 6, 1989 Article (Douglass County Herald)

Unsolved Slaying Haunts Family (Springfield News Leader, 1990, via Newspapers.com)

24 Year Old Woman Missing Since Friday (Douglas County Herald, 1989, via Newspapers.com)

Body of Missing Woman Found in Christian County (Douglas County Herald, 1989, via Newspapers.com)

Slaying Suspect Sticks by Alibi in Workman Case (Springfield News Leader, 1995, via Newspapers.com)

July 1996 Article (Springfield News Leader, 1996, via Newspapers.com)

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: DIANA VICARI

When a young Tucson, Arizona woman goes missing, her partial remains are discovered in a dumpster just days later. Potential suspects and unanswered questions haunt a case gone cold in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Mystery Shrouds 1992 Murder (Gabrielle Fimbres / The Tucson Citizen)

Diana Dawn Vicari (The Arizona Daily Star)

State v. Prion (2002) Supreme Court of Arizona (Supreme Court of Arizona via FindLaw.com)

State v. Lemuel Prion CR-99-0378-AP, Oral Argument Case Summary (Arizona Supreme Court)

Arizona Daily Star, Tuesday, October 27th, 1992 Ed., Page 2 (Arizona Daily Star via Newspapers.com)

Utah Inmate Indicted in 1992 Slaying (Deseret News)

The National Registry of Exonerations: Lemuel Prion (Alexandra Gross / University of Michigan Law School)

Woman Involved In ‘Brutalized’ Abuse Of Her Baby As a Teen Granted New Look At 1993 Case (Terri Jo Neff / Arizona Daily Independent)

ANGELA RENE LEEMAN v. STATE OF ARIZONA (Supreme Court of the United States)

ANGELA RENE LEEMAN, PETITIONER V. STATE OF ARIZONA, RESPONDENT (Supreme Court of the United States)

Mother, Boyfriend Sentenced to Life for ‘Atrocities’ Inflicted on 8-Month-Old (Joe Salkowski / Arizona Daily Star)

Tucson’s Top Unsolved Crimes (David Teibal / The Tucson Citizen)

If you know anything about the death of Diana Vicari, please call the Tucson Police Department directly at 520-791-4444 OR if you’d prefer to submit a tip anonymously, call 520-882-7463, or go to 88crime.org.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: BIANCA PIPER

When a girl goes missing from rural Missouri, hopes that she simply became lost during a walk are quickly extinguished. Investigators pursue answers in the potential abduction of a vulnerable child in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Sheriff to Implement a Cold Case Unit; Piper Disappearance Tops on The List (Shawn Singleton / Lincoln News Now)

Family Marking 10th Anniversary of Missing Foley Girl with Fading Hope (Susan Weich / St. Louis Post Dispatch)

Lincoln County Cold Case Gets Renewed Hope (First Alert 4 News)

‘You think about it every day’ | 13 years since Bianca Piper disappeared (Rachel Menitoff / KSDK News)

Historical Temperature Record: Foley, MO, March 10th, 2005 (wunderground.com)

Michael Devlin: Suspect is Called ‘Kind of a Plain Guy’ (Jeremy Kohler / St. Louis Post Dispatch)

What Happened to Convicted Kidnapper Michael J. Devlin? (William Kennedy / Grunge)

One Search, Two Boys Found: A Look Back at the Missouri Miracle (Tim O’Neil / The Southern Illinoisan)

The Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Efforts to Combat Crimes Against Children (FBI / US DOJ)

Pizza Manager’s Links to 1991 Abduction Investigated (KLTV News)

22 Years After Attempted Abduction, Victim Says He Learned it Was Michael Devlin (KMOV News)

The Relationship Between Victim Age and Gender Crossover Among Sex Offenders (Jill S. Levenson et al. / Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment, March 2008 Edition)

Suicide and Suicide Risk in Adolescents (Liwei L. Hua, MD, PhD et al. / American Academy of Pediatrics)

Mother of Missing Girl is Charged with Assault (Susan Weich / St. Louis Post-Dispatch)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Bianca Piper, please contact the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office at 636-528-8546.

FINAL STEPS: COLD CASES FEATURING MISSING / MURDERED RUNNERS AND PEDESTRIANS

From quick errands to long runs, the cold cases included in this episode feature stories of victims who set out on foot and never returned home. Each of these little-known cases are in critical need of tips from the public, so join us as we retrace the final steps of four separate victims in this special multi-case episode of Last Seen Alive.

Stories in this episode include:

  • The 1979 murder of North Carolina college student Tammy Aldridge, who went for a run while visiting home during a break and was waylaid by a cruel killer.
  • The 1981 disappearance of small-town Pennsylvania teenager Michele Reidenbach, who walked just a block away from her place of work on an errand, and vanished without a trace.
  • The 1990 cold case murder of Jennifer Bailey, who set out for a jog on a popular Kentucky running trail, only to be fatally attacked by a man who has remained unidentified for more than 30 years.
  • The 2011 murder of 23-year-old David Grubbs, who was brutally attacked and killed while walking along an Oregon bike path on his way home from work.

Unsolved Homicide: Tammy Aldridge

UPDATE: Tammy’s case has been solved. An update episode is available wherever you listen to podcasts.

Tammy Aldridge was 20-years-old when she was murdered in June of 1979 just outside of Burlington, North Carolina.. Evidence indicates that she was likely abducted while out for a run. Her killer remains unidentified.

Sources used to research Tammy Aldridge’s case:

Body in Whiteford Township Exhumed for DNA in Unsolved North Carolina Slaying (The Toledo Blade)

Tammy Aldridge Murder Case Reopened in Alamance County (Carter Coyle / Fox8 News)

The Herald Sun, November 8, 1985 Edition, Page 1 (The Herald Sun via Newspapapers.com)

The Herald Sun, November 8, 1985 Edition, Page 3 (The Herald Sun via Newspapers.com)

The Herald Sun, November 14th, 1985 Edition, Page 3 (The Herald Sun via Newspapers.com)

The News and Record, July 10, 1985 Edition, Page 20 (The News and Record via Newspapers.com)

The Burlington Times News, August 5, 2012 Edition, Page2 (The Burlington Times News via NewspaperArchive.com)

If you know anything about the murder of Tammy Aldridge, please call the Alamance County Sheriff’s Office at 336-570-6300.

Unsolved Disappearance: Michele Reidenbach

Michele Reidenbach was 16-years-old when she went missing from Zelienople, Pennsylvania in 1981. She has not been seen since.

Sources used to research Michele Reidenbach’s Case:

Unsolved Cases: Michele Reidenbach Disappeared After Posing for Seneca Valley Senior Photo (Sandy Dudiak / Patch.com)

Bleak Holiday for Missing Girl’s Mom (Carol Patton / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Case of Missing Harmony Teenager Still Being Investigated 42 Years Later (Molly Miller / The Butler Eagle)

North Hill News Record, November 3, 1993, Page 6 (North Hill News Record via Newspapers.com)

Police Reopen Case of Missing Girl (Allegheny Times, September 22, 1993 Edition)

Pittsburgh Post Gazette, May 12, 1989 Edition, Page 4 (Pittsburgh Post Gazette via Newspapers.com)

Christine Guenther’s Murder Remains Unsolved (Sarah Beth Martin / Patch.com)

Pittsburgh Press October 28, 1988 Edition, Page 1 (Pittsburgh Post Gazette via Newspapers.com)

If you have any information related to the disappearance of Michele Reidenbach, please contact the Pennsylvania State Police at 724-284-8100. OR, if you prefer to submit your tip online and / or to remain anonymous, go to crimewatchpa.com. 

Unsolved Homicide: Jennifer Bailey

Jennifer Bailey was 21-years-old when she was murdered in Bell County, Kentucky in August of 1990. Her killer remains unidentified.

Sources used to research Jennifer Bailey’s Case:

Parents Tireless in Their Efforts to Find Daughter’s Killer (Lexington Herald Leader via Newspapers.com)

“Someone knows what happened” | Detectives Release New Details in 30-Year-Old Cold Case (Cole Sullivan / WBIR News)

Mother of Murdered Daughter: ‘It’ll Never be Solved, I Don’t Believe’ (Taylor Upchurch / WYMT News)

The State Journal, September 7th 1990 Edition, Page 13 (The State Journal via Newspapers.com)

Lexington Herald Leader, August 20th, 1990 Edition, Page 12 (The Lexington Herald-Leader via Newspapers.com)

The Lust Murderer (Robert R. Hazlewood and John E. Douglass / FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, April 1980 Edition)

Lexington Herald Leader, January 19th, 1992 Edition, Page 1 (Lexington Herald Leader via Newspapers.com)

If you have any information on the murder of Jennifer Bailey—or on the murder of Greta Henson—please call the Kentucky State Police Post 10 at 606-573-3131.

Unsolved Homicide: David Grubbs

David Grubbs was 23-years-old when he was murdered in Ashland, Oregon in November of 2011. His killer remains unidentified.

Sources used to research David Grubb’s case:

Horrific Murder Shatters Sense of Safety in Ashland (Jeff Barnard / KVAL News)

Community Still Looking for Answers in Violent 2011 Murder of David Grubbs on Ashland, Oregon Bike Path (Sarah Portney / NBC News)

New Details Emerge on Killing of Ashland Man 8 Years After His Death (Carsyn Currier / KTLV News)

Decapitation of Young Ashland Man Remains Unsolved 7 Years Later (Fe’lisha LaCher / KPIC News)

Police: Only Lead in Decapitation Case is Video Game (Jeff Barnard / The Tribute Democrat)

David Grubbs’ Mother Talks for First Time Since Son’s Murder (Kobi5 News)

Ten-Years After Unsolved Ashland Murder, Friends Remember David Grubbs (Kobi5 News)

‘What Should We Save?’ In Flight From Southern Oregon Wildfire, Mother Preserves Memory of Murdered Son (Noelle Crombie / OregonLive.com)

Christian Delaurentiis, Who Put Roommate’s Dismembered Body in Freezer, ‘Deserves No Mercy,’ Victim’s Sister Says (Emily E. Smith / OregonLive.com)

If you have any information related to the death of David Grubbs, call the Ashland Police Department at 541-552-2333. Or, if you’d prefer to remain anonymous, you can call or text Crime Stoppers of Southern Oregon at 1-800-850-0580.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: GRETCHEN FLEMING

When a West Virginia woman leaves a bar with a former police officer on a winter night in 2022, she’s never seen again. Diligent investigators close in on an ex-cop with an unlikely story and an unsettling reputation in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Disappeared: S11 E8 – Gone With the Night (Investigation Discovery)

Police Search for ‘Person of Interest’ Vehicle in Gretchen Fleming Disappearance (MetroNews Staff / WV Metro News)

Parkersburg Police Back at Person of Interest’s Home as Search for Missing Woman Continues (Leslie Rubin and Bob Aaron / WCHS News)

Parkersburg Police Chief: Gretchen Fleming Case ‘Not Even Close’ to Cold (The Intelligencer)

Gretchen Fleming’s Family Discuss Law Enforcement Outsourcing Evidence to Outside Agencies (Mitchel Blahut / WTAP News)

Grandmother of Missing Wood County Woman Believes “She’s Gone” as Police Continue Investigating One Year Later (Carrie Hodousek / WV Metro News)

Update: Calhoun Man Suffers Serious Head Injury in Glenville (Drew Moody / Hur Herald)

Parkersburg P.D. Waiting on D.N.A. and Forensic Evidence to Come Back (Mitchell Blahut / WTAP News)

Why Virginia Police Hired ‘Catfish’ Cop Austin Lee Edwards (Summer Lin / Erin B. Logan / Los Angeles Times)

If you have any information on the disappearance of Gretchen Fleming, please call the Parkersburg Police Department at 304-424-8444. If you wish to submit a tip anonymously, you can do so online at ppd.parkersburgwv.gov.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: PAUL FUGATE

When a National Park Service Ranger vanishes from his post in the Arizona mountains, he’s never seen again. Questions endure in the strange and controversial case of the only National Park Service Ranger to ever go missing—and never be found—in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Missing for Four Decades: Unsolved Park Ranger Mystery Lingers in Southern Arizona (Ryan Fish / KGUN9 News)

The Search for a Ranger Who Was Lost and Never Found (Brendan Borrell / Outside Magazine)

Chiricahua National Monument Arizona (National Park Service)

The Mystery of a Missing Naturalist May Lead to Legal Test of Dismissal (New York Times)

Los Angeles Times, Tuesday, July 13th, 1982 Edition, Page 51 (Los Angeles Times)

Reward Triples in Decades-Old Disappearance of Chiricahua National Monument Ranger (NPS Investigative Services)

Man Charges in NPS Employee Assault (Ainslee S. Wittig and Carol Broeder / Arizona Range News)

Chiricahua National Monument / Lillian Erickson Riggs (NPS.gov)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Paul Fugate, please call the National Park Service’s Investigative Services Branch at  888-653-0009. Or, submit a tip online by clicking HERE.

UNSOLVED DOUBLE-HOMICIDE: NEAL AND BRENDAN ABERNATHY

When a mild-mannered father and his 12-year-old son are shot execution-style inside their Bay Area home, there’s no apparent motive. Investigators are puzzled by one of the most unlikely homicides in suburban California history in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Ten Years Later, Police Take New Look at Killings of Father, Son: SENSELESS CRIME STILL A MYSTERY (Karl Fischer / East Bay Times)

Cherished Memories of Home / Woman surviving horror of slayings (Suzanne Espinosa-Solis / SF Gate)

Obituary: Neal Edwin Abernathy (findagrave.com)

Reward Doubled in Hercules Killings / Father, Son Found Slain in Family Home (Henry K. Lee / SF Gate)

Website Created by a Friend of the Abernathy Family: The Abernathy Murders, February 19, 1997 (rocks4brains.com)

Shattered Nerves in Hercules / Double Killing Destroys Sense of Security (Suzanne Espinosa-Solis)

Hercules Jolted by Shooting Deaths of Father, Son / Dual-Killing is Close-Knit City’s First (Erin Hallissy / Chronicle East Bay Bureau)

Overview of PROMIS (Prosecutor’s Management Information System) (US DOJ, Office of Justice Programs)

The INSLAW Octopus (Richard L. Fricker / Wired)

If you know anything about the murders of Neal and Brendan Abernathy, please call the Hercules Police Department at 510-799-8260.

BREAKING UPDATE: ALLEGED KILLER CHARGED WITH THE 2003 MURDER OF REBECCA PARK

When a medical student and military reserve officer disappears during a run through a Philadelphia park, foul play is immediately suspected. The discovery of her body incriminates a deadly serial offender who is finally identified and charged in this special breaking update episode of Last Seen Alive.

We originally aired an episode on Rebecca’s unsolved murder in 2020. In December of 2023, Philadelphia police identified Elias Diaz, age 46, as Rebecca’s alleged killer. He was charged with her murder–and an assortment of related charges–on December 20th, 2023 (see charges listed on court document below). Bail was denied. He has also been charged in relation to two other attacks committed in November of 2023. The total number of his victims isn’t known for sure, and Philadelphia Police are seeking any information that could lead to additional charges against Diaz.

Sources used to research this episode:

Suspect in Pennypack Trail Slashings Charged with 2003 Fairmount Park Rape and Murder (NBC10 Staff / NBC10 Philadelphia)

Man Charged in 20-Year-Old Philadelphia Cold Case Killing and Rape After DNA Link, Officials Say (Celina Tebor and Danny Freeman / CNN)

Elias Diaz charged with 2003 Philadelphia cold case murder of Rebecca Park (Alexandra Simon, Aliza Shuler and Joe Holden / CBS News Philadelphia)

Runner’s Life Was Rife with Promise, Rebecca Park’s Friends and Family Recall Her Strength, Energy (Natalie Pompilio / Philadelphia Enquirer)

Body Identified as Missing Student in Philadelphia (Los Angeles Times)

Literally the Calvary: Meet the Philadelphia Police Department’s Mounted Cops (Billy Penn)

Running While Female (Runner’s World / Michelle Hamilton)

FBI, Police Continue Search for Fairmount Park Rapist 16 Years Later (NBC Philadelphia)

DNA Tool May Help in Fairmount Park Rapist Cold Case (ABC6)

Search Continues for Fairmount Park Rapist (Northeast Times / William Kenny)

If you have any information that could lead to additional charges against Diaz, please call 215-686-8477 to report what you know to Philadelphia Police.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: LISA IRWIN

When an infant goes missing from her crib in Kansas City, initial signs suggest the possibility of a rare stranger abduction. Investigators scrutinize several individuals as they attempt to determine whether a missing baby was truly kidnapped in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Search Intensifies For Missing Mo. Baby Lisa Irwin (Camille Mann / CBS News)

Is Missing Baby Lisa Irwin Dead? Unsettling Questions Remain (Julia Greenberg / International Business Times)

Surveillance Video From Night Girl Disappeared Turned Over to Authorities (CNN Wire Staff / CNN)

Baby Lisa Irwin: New Surveillance Footage of Mystery Man (ABC News)

Lisa Irwin Search Warrant Reveals Cadaver Dog ‘Hit’ (KMBC News)

Missing Baby Lisa’s Parents Make Emotional Plea for Her Return (ABC News)

Report: Timeline Emerges in Lisa Irwin Disappearance (Crimesider Staff / CBS News)

Mother: I Was Drunk When Missouri Infant Disappeared (CNN Wire Staff / CNN)

Police Search Baby Lisa’s Home (Jane Velez-Mitchell / CNN Transcripts)

Missing Baby Lisa: Family Attorney Says Cadaver Dogs May be Misleading Officials (ABC News)

Where Americans Die — Is There Really “No Place Like Home”? (Melissa W. Wachterman, M.D., M.P.H et al. / New England Journal of Medicine)

How Cadaver Dogs Help Find Dead Bodies (Mara Bovsun / American Kennel Club)

HRD Dogs: CoronerTalk Podcast (CoronerTalk Podcast feat. Guest Barbara Weakly-Jones MD)

Scientists Search for Death’s Aroma (Sarah Everts / Chemical & Engineering News)

Sigma Pseudo™ Corpse Scent (sigmaaldrich.com)

How Cadaver Dogs Are Trained to Help Authorities Locate Human Remains (Rob Earnshaw / Chicago Tribune)

Analysis of Bacterial Vaginosis-Related Amines in Vaginal Fluid by Gas Chromatography and Mass Spectrometry (Helen Wolrath et al. / Journal of Clinical Microbiology)

Phone Owner in Baby Lisa Irwin Case Answers Questions on Facebook (Samantha Murphy / NBC News)

Lawyer: Phone Call Clears Baby Lisa’s Parents (Today)

Woman’s Cell Phone Confiscated for Baby Lisa Investigation (Eric Burke / Fox4 News)

Missing Baby Lisa Irwin: Teen Denies Rumor of Handyman ‘Jersey’ Kidnapping Infant for $300 (Ankita Mehta / International Business Times)

Missing Baby Lisa Irwin Update: Man Linked to Disappearance Arrested for Unrelated Stabbing Incident (Julia Greenberg / International Business Times)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Lisa Irwin, please call the Kansas City Police Department at 816-234-5136.