UNSOLVED TRIPLE-DISAPPEARANCE: PAUL SKIBA, SARAH SKIBA AND LORENZO CHIVERS

When a Colorado man brings his young daughter to work for a day, they both vanish under highly-suspicious circumstances, along with another employee. Investigators search for answers in a presumed case of triple-homicide in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Over 25 Years After Triple Murder, Westminster Police Are Breaking New Ground in Case (Hannah Metzger / Westword)

A Cold Case Frozen in Time (Jessica Centers / Westwood)

‘Sarah Deserves to be Found.’ Colorado Mom Seeks Help in Missing Girl’s 1999 Cold Case (Sara Schilling / Sacramento Bee)

New Evidence in 1999 Triple-Homicide Could Crack Cold Case, Police Say (Adria Iraheta / Denver 7 News)

Ambush Suspected After Man, Daughter Vanish (CNN)

Arvada Man Sentenced to 28 Years in Prison After Stabbing of Mother (Anthony Cotton / The Denver Post)

Obituary: Sharon Lee Skiba (legacy.com)

If you know anything about the disappearances of Paul Skiba, Sarah Skiba and Lorenzo Chivers, please contact the Westminster PD at 303-658-4360.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: THERESA WOODS

When a teen vanishes from her small West Virginia hometown, no trace of her is found until her remains are discovered in a backwoods stream months later. A present-day lead results in the reopening of a heartbreaking cold case in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

25 Years Later, Father Still Waits for Justice Over Daughter’s Killing (Susan Williams / The Charleston Gazette)

Cold Case Reopened by West Virginia Authorities (Jessica Farrish / The Register-Herald)

Murder of Oak Hill Teen Remains Unsolved Nearly 40 Years Later (Austin Simms / Lootpress)

“Unresolved Lives” Book Pays Tribute to Survivors (Cheryl Keenan / Fayette Tribune)

Unresolved Lives (Susan Williams)

Jury Finds Carroll Not Guilty of Murder (Matthew Hill / Fayette Tribune)

UI Study Examines Perpetrators of Child Homicides in the U.S., Use of Guns (University of Iowa)

If you know anything about the murder of Theresa Woods, please contact the West Virginia Crime Stoppers at 304-255-7867. You can remain anonymous if you wish. Or, share what you know directly with the West Virginia State Police HERE via their online tip form.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: JOANIE HALL

When a small-town Oregon teen vanishes on her way to her after-school job, thorough searches prove fruitless, and investigators suspect foul play. Multiple potential suspects arise in a heartbreaking search for the truth in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Vigil Set for Warrenton Woman Missing Since 1983 (Associated Press)

Where is Joanie Hall? (Chelsea Gorrow / The Daily Astorian)

Search Intensified for Missing Warrenton Girl (The Daily Astorian)

Leads Go Nowhere in Search for Missing Girl (The Daily Astorian)

Foul Play Suspected in Girl’s Disappearance (The Daily Astorian)

Reward Increases (The Bulletin)

Search Fails to Turn Up Any Leads (Lesley Fornas / The Daily Astorian)

Search Turns Up Nothing (The Daily Astorian)

‘Vision’ Fails to Turn Up Missing Girl (Statesman Journal)

Memories Highlight Vigil for Joan Hall (Chelsea Gorrow / The Daily Astorian)

Missing My Sister (Becky Hall / The Daily Astorian)

National Missing Children’s Day Carries a Certain Irony (The Daily Astorian)

Vigil on Saturday for Long-Missing Girl (Seaside Signal)

Basch vs. Basch (Alameda County Superior Courts via trellis.law)

Seaside Police Officer Heads Academy Class (Seaside Signal)

Slain Girl’s Parents Still Grieving as Man Scheduled for Release (Associated Press)

‘It’s like being stabbed with a knife–every day’ (Associated Press)

Suspect Name in Girl’s Disappearance (Joan Herman / The Daily Astorian)

Mullins Not Released, Gets Heavier Charges (Don Cullimore / Seaside Signal)

Ratermans Still Grieve for Slain Daughter (Associated Press)

Lieutenant Seeks Sheriff’s Post (The Daily Astorian)

Third-Annual Clatsop ‘Mini School’ Offers Wallpapering, Home Security Suggestions (Seaside Signal)

Wife Told Ex-Sheriff: ‘Don’t Go’ (The Daily Astorian)

Sentence Sparks Anger (Fred Leeson and Don Cullimore / The Oregonian)

Eastman Faces New Charges (John Sowell / Seaside Signal)

Eastman Meted Five Years (John Sowell / Seaside Signal)

Abducted Portland Girl Found in Reno (Associated Press)

Ghosts of Highway 20 (Noelle Crombie / The Oregonian)

Details of Plea Deal in 1990 Cold Case Killing Finally Revealed (Noelle Crombie / The Oregonian)

Oldest DNA Match in Interpol’s History Links Dead American Convict to Highway of Tears Victim (Wawmeesh Hamilton / ICT News)

Unsealed Records Renew Interest in Cold Case (Jasmine Lewin / Seaside Signal)

Judge to Lift Protective Order in Cold Case (Jasmine Lewin / The Daily Astoria)

If you know anything about the disappearance or whereabouts of Joanie Hall, please call the Clatsop County Sheriff’s Office at (503) 325-2061.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE / DISAPPEARANCE: BILL AND KAY WOOD

When an elderly Iowa man is found deceased in the ashes of a suspicious housefire, investigators determine not only that he was murdered, but that his wife is nowhere to be found. Investigators attempt to piece together who may’ve been responsible for the murder of one unlikely victim and the disappearance of another in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Investigators Seeking More Information in 3-Year-Old Unsolved Warren County Murder Case (Dar Danielson / Radio Iowa)

Man Sought in Missing-Couple Case (Daniel P. Finney / The Des Moines Register)

Person Of Interest Sought In Missing Couple Case (KCCI News)

Missing Person / NamUs #MP11855: Kaidena Lozelle Wood (NAMUS)

Search Expands for Clues on Missing Couple (Tom Alex / The Des Moines Register)

Wood Search: The Family of a Missing Woman Continues the Search (WHO13 News)

Mystery Behind Couple’s Death, Disappearance Continues (KCCI News)

Obituary: James William Wood (Overton Funeral Home)

One Year Later, Children Find Little Closure in Wood Case (Emily Schettler and Regina Zilbermints / The Des Moines Register)

Norwalk Murder, Woman’s Disappearance Unsolved (Associated Press)

Family Searching for Answers in Bill, Kay Wood Case (Tom Alex / The Des Moines Register)

Wood Family Sets Up Reward Fund Website (Sara Sleyster / The Des Moines Register)

Reward Offered in Wood Investigation (The Des Moines Register)

5 Years Later: Investigators Narrow Search in Deadly Mystery (Kim St Onge / KCCI News)

Iowa Cold Case Unit Unveils Playing Card Deck to Generate New Leads (KCCI News)

Age Patterns of Victims of Serious Violent Crime (Craig A. Perkins / BJS Statistician)

Homicide Rates Across County, Race, Ethnicity, Age and Sex in the US: A Global Burden of Disease Study (Paula D Strassle et al. / JAMA Network Open)

If you know anything about the death of Bill Wood or the disappearance of Kay Wood, please contact the Iowa Attorney General’s Office at 1-800-242-5100.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: JACK PHILLIPS

When a young Big Bear Lake, California boy disappears from a playground near his home, authorities launch the most extensive missing person search the area has ever seen. Finding no trace of the child, investigators attempt to solve his presumed abduction in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Have you seen this child? Jack Daniel Phillips (NCMEC)

Hunt Continues for Big Bear Lake Boy Missing 2 Weeks (Tom Gorman / LA Times)

Authorities Halt Ground Search for 9-Year-Old Boy (Lynn Anderson / The San Bernardino County Sun via newspapers.com)


Public’s Help Sought in Search for Missing Boy : Appeal: Nine-Year-Old Was Last Seen Aug. 6 After Parade Near Big Bear Lake. Authorities Want to Scrutinize Home Videos of the Event for Clues (Tom Gorman / LA Times)

Cate Jailed on Failure-to-Appear Warrant (Judi Bowers / Big Bear Grizzly)

‘Please Don’t Forget’ (Judi Bowers / Big Bear Grizzly)

Cynthia Kudish (Big Bear Grizzly via newspapers.com)

Search Continues for Missing Youth, Clues Slim, Officials Say (Judi Bowers / Big Bear Grizzly via newspapers.com)

Closure Eludes Parents of Missing Big Bear Lake Boy (Joe Nelson / The Sun)

Child Molester on Death Row Commits Suicide (Mike Reicher / LA Times)

Convicted killer James Lee Crummel Commits Suicide Before Disclosing Info in San Bernardino Cold Case (ABC7 News)

Sergeant Devotes Years to Putting Molester Behind Bars (Lori Basheda / The Orange County Register)

O.C. Child Killer’s Twisted Road to Death Row ( Lori Basheda / Orange County Register)

Murder Trial Begins 25 Years After Teenage Boy Vanished (Lance Pugmire / LA Times)

Freeway Killer’s Accomplice Recants His Story in Court (Lance Pugmire / LA Times)

Officials Concerned Molester May Return (Roger Beck / Big Bear Grizzly)

Police Grill Molester About Old Murder (Associated Press via The Californian)

Molestation Suspect Pleads Not Guilty (Richard Brooks / The San Bernardino County Sun)

Missing Person: Roderick Lester Cate (California Department of Justice)

Climate and Average Weather Year Round in Big Bear Lake (weatherspark.com)

If you  know anything about the disappearance of Jack Philips, please contact the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department at 909-387-8313.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: LUCY MEADOWS

When a toddler vanishes from the parking lot of a popular Tennessee mall, she’s the third child to disappear from the area within just weeks. Fearing that she was abducted, local police launch an investigation that takes years’ worth of twists and turns in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Without a Clue (The Commercial Appeal via newspapers.com)

Unsolved TN: What Happened to Toddler Who Vanished from RiverGate Mall in 1996? (Sierra Rains / WKRN News)

Abductions Stir Fear, Strength (Stephanie Broadbent / The Daily News via newspapers.com)

Searches Continue (The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

Three Mothers of Kidnap Victims to Plead for Daughters (The Commercial Appeal via newspapers.com)

Lucy’s Sister Says Child Held for Debt (Catherine Trevison / The Tennesseean via newspapers.com)

William Glenn Rogers v. State of Tennessee (Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee at Nashville via JUSTIA US Law)

Seeking Information | Unknown Suspect: Kidnapping and Murder, Bowling Green Kentucky, July 24, 1996 (FBI.gov)

Police Doubt Mom’s Story of Tot’s Mall Disappearance (Catherine Trevison / The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

‘Deception’ Concerns Police (Jill Noelle Cecil / The Leaf-Chronicle via newspapers.com)

Missing Lucy: A Mother’s Story Unfolds (Catherine Trevison / The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

Police Have Witnesses in Disappearance (The Messenger via newspapers.com)

Divorce Testimony Cites Missing Child (Catherine Trevison / The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

One Year Later, Girl Still Missing (Diane Tsimekles / The Leaf-Chronicle via newspapers.com)

Police Release Updated Photo of Missing Girl (Catherine Trevison / The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

Lucy Meadows’ Father Fears People Will Forget His Girl (Catherine Trevison / The Tennessean via newspapers.com)

Girl Just Looked Like Missing Child (The Daily News Journal via newspapers.com)

Yong Mun Chong Meadows vs. Tommy C. Meadows (Court of Appeals of Tennessee at Nashville)

Child Murder by Mothers; Patterns and Prevention (Susan Hatters Friedman and Phillip J Resnick / World Psychiatry via the National Library of Medicine)

Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report: Murder in Families (John M. Dawson, Patrick A. Langan, Ph.D., and BJS Statisticians)

Witness May Resolved 1996 Case, Police Say (Christian Bottorff / The Tennessean)

If you have any information on the disappearance or whereabouts of Lucy Meadows, please contact the Goodlettsville Police Department at 615-851-2236 or the TBI at 1-800-TBI-FIND.

UNSOLVED DISAPPEARANCE: ISRAEL SMITH

When a man vanishes from small-town Virginia without a trace, investigators face the most perplexing case of their careers. The enduring mystery of the whereabouts of a loving son and father is explored in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Missing Person / NamUs #MP2828 Israel Ray Smith (NamUS)

Police Suspect Foul Play in Case of Missing Wytheville Man (WSLS10 News)

Police Search for Missing Wythe Man (Nate Hubbard / SWVA Today)

Missing Man Remains a Mystery (Nate Hubbard / SWVA Today)

Family Searches for Answers for 13 Years (Jasmine Franks / Clinch Valley News and Richlands Press via newspapers.com)

Still Missing (Jasmine Franks / Wytheville Enterprise via newspapers.com)

Crime in Virginia 2007 (Virginia State Police)

If you know anything about the disappearance of Israel Smith, please call the Wytheville Police Department at 276-223-3300.

UNSOLVED DOUBLE-DISAPPEARANCE: SCOTT AND TRACY HAWKINS

When two brothers retreat into the woods of Appalachian Tennessee to forage for ginseng in 2021, they vanish without a trace. Their unexplained absence haunts their family and community in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Campbell Co. Sheriff Searching for Two Men Who Disappeared While Ginseng Hunting (WBIR Staff / WBIR News)

Caleb County Brothers Missing After Leaving Home to Search for Ginseng (Caleb Wethington / WATE6 News)

Authorities Searching for Missing Brothers (WYSH Radio)

Two Brothers Missing From Rocky Top (Kelly Ann Kreuger and Paige Hill / WVLT News)

“I’ve got to find my sons” | Mother Pleads for Tips in Case of Campbell Co. Brothers Missing for 48 Days (Cole Sullivan / WBIR10 News)

Around Three Years Later, a Campbell County Mother is Still Searching for Her Missing Sons (Ellis Rold / WBIR10 News)

Two Campbell County Brothers Still Missing After Nearly Four Years (Sam Luther / WVLT8 News)

Authorities Make Largest Tennessee Marijuana Find Ever – More Than 350,000 Plants (Times News)

More Than $1M of Marijuana Destroyed in East TN (WBIR10 News)

Obituary: Daniel Hawkins Sr (Hatmaker Funeral Home)

Illegal Cannabis Grow Sites (US Forest Service)

Appalachia High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area Drug Market Analysis (National Drug Intelligence Center)


Tennessee Caves (and the Bats That Use Them) (The Nature Conservancy)

Operation Root Cause: Diggers, Dealers, and the Case for Wild Ginseng (US Fish and Wildlife Service)

Ginseng Program (Department of Environment & Conservation)

Growing American Ginseng (Panax quinquefolius) in Forestlands (Virginia Cooperative Extension / US Forest Service)

If you know anything about the double-disappearance of Scott and Tracy Hawkins, please contact the Campbell County Sheriff’s Office at: 423-562-7446. Or, if you prefer to remain anonymous, call 423-566-3784.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: ALICIA HUMMEL

When an Iowa woman ventures out to spend a summer afternoon unwinding on the banks of a South Dakotan river, she’s ambushed by an opportunistic predator. Investigators believe they’re facing the rarest type of murder—a true stranger killing—in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Timeline: A Walk Through Alicia Hummel’s Final Day (Jacob Newton / Siouxland Proud)

Obituary: Alicia M. Hummel (Christy-Smith Funeral Homes)

They Discovered This Preschool Teacher’s Body Floating in the Missouri River. Yet the Case is Far From Cold. (Trisha Taurinskas / Sioux Falls Live)

She Died Fishing on a Summer Day. Three Years Later, Police Still Don’t Know Who Killed Her. (Danielle Ferguson / Argus Leader)

Murder at Myron Grove (Angela Kennecke / KELO News)

Who Killed Alicia? (Garrett Looker / The Sioux City Journal)

Hummel: Death Investigated as Homicide (The Sioux City Journal)

South Dakota Authorities Seek Answers in Unsolved 2015 Death (Danielle Ferguson / Associated Press)

If you know anything about the death of Alicia Hummel, please contact the Clay County Sheriff’s Office at 605-677-7100.

UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: SARAH SAGANITSO

When an Arizona woman fails to return home from her late-night shift at the hospital where she works, her family and friends launch a search and locate her battered body. Her accused killer raises one of the most outrageous defenses ever entertained in criminal court in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Sources used to research this episode:

Out There: Crimes of the Paranormal, Episode 6 (Hulu)

Hospital Employee Murdered (Mary Tolan / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Obituary: Sarah L. Saganitso (Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Body of Stabbed, Beaten Flagstaff Hospital Worker Found (Mark Shaffer / The Arizona Republic via newspapers.com)

Suffocation Caused Death (Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Versions Conflict in Suspect’s Murder Story (Steve Ryan / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Police Arrest Suspect in June Murder (Ted Bartimus / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Videos Show Murder Suspect Interrogation (Steve Ryan / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Attorneys Argue Whether Wound from Bite, Knife (Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Judge Gives Probe Data to Abney Counsel (Ted Bartimus / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Pastor Tells of Member’s Killing Dream (Arizona Daily Star via newspapers.com)

Mystery Suspect Surfaces (Ted Bartimus / Arizona Sun via newspapers.com)

Defendant is Acquitted of Murder (AP / The Arizona Republic via newspapers.com)

Videos Show Murder Suspect Interrogation (Steve Ryan / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Death Clues, Navajo Witchcraft Linked by Prof at Murder Trial (Mark Shaffer / The Arizona Republic via newspapers.com)

Experts Say Bitemark as Good as a Fingerprint (Steve Ryan / Arizona Daily Sun via newspapers.com)

Skinwalker (Mythology) (EBSCO)

If you know anything about the death of Sarah Saganitso, please contact the Flagstaff Police Department at 928-774-1414.